Skip to main content

2026 FAMILY, PRIVATELY OWNED AND OWNER-MANAGED BUSINESS SURVEY

Download now

Occupying Land - get the paperwork right

In this article I will be talking about a recent Scottish Land Court case concerning a dispute between a landlord and tenant of an Aberdeenshire farm. This case – Fyffe v Esslemont – concerned a landlord trying to bring a tenancy to an end, but the issues raised can equally apply to taxation.

In brief, the case revolved around whether the tenant was undertaking any agricultural activity, or instead had breached his tenancy by subletting the land. The farm had two separate areas of land:

  1. Grassland which were subject to seasonal grazing, whereby neighbouring farmers brought their sheep onto the land. The problem here was that there was no paperwork and it was unclear which party was undertaking the husbandry on the land.
  2. Arable land which was subject to a Contract farming Agreement. The contractor was a neighbouring arable farmer who did all the cultivation work etc. and then purchased the standing crop. The issue here was that the price paid seems to have been fixed and did not vary according to the condition of the crop.

The Land Court decided that there was no agricultural activity and the landlord gained vacant possession of the farm. For tax purposes there are a number of consequences if the owner of the land cannot show that they are an active farmer:

  • Inheritance Tax relief will usually still be available on the land, but there will be no relief on the farmhouse. This is because there is no “working farmer” living in the house.
  • The higher rate of Capital Gains Tax is likely to be payable on a future sale of the land. Similarly Rollover Relief is restricted if an asset has been rented out for part of the period of ownership.
  • For income tax purposes the income is taxed as rent, which means there are fewer expenses which can be offset, and profits cannot be averaged.
  • For VAT purposes rental income is usually exempt from VAT which restricts the reclaim of VAT on expenses. In some cases it might mean that the business cannot be VAT registered at all.

In conclusion it is important that the landowner is involved in the farming activities on the land and can show that they are taking some commercial risk. This may entail additional paperwork but this should be considered money well spent given the amount of tax potentially at stake.

Subscribe to
Agri Matters

Agri Matters is our quarterly online newsletter that provides you with the latest financial information and legislation updates affecting British farming businesses.

Subscribe

Recent news stories

Cyber security specialist analysing digital network activity and code across multiple computer screens

20th November 2026

What is Defence Cyber Certification (DCC) and does your business need it?

Traditional stone-built residential properties overlooking a tree-lined street with autumn foliage and soft evening light.

19th November 2026

Will Holyrood follow Westminster on property income tax in the Scottish Budget?

Hand interacting with a tablet and laptop displaying digital financial dashboards, charts, analytics graphs and performance metrics.

18th November 2026

What should trustees expect from their charity's management accounts?

Armstrong Watson can help

Whether you need expert accounting, strategic business advisory, tax planning, or financial guidance, our experienced team is here to support your success. From sole traders to large enterprises, we provide tailored solutions to help you navigate complex financial challenges and achieve your goals. Get in touch today to discover how we can help your business thrive – call 0808 144 5575.

Contact the team